- cmrcn3xe200bk13vzrvoavi4u← DERIVED_FROM
which-came-first: debt derives from gift; debt is formalized gift that creates obligation.
- cmrcn46oe00bt13vznm80qbr1← DEPENDS_ON
Hospitality creates gift/debt cycles; without gift, hospitality is mere charity.
- cmrcnnaet00or13vzpj13r52k← DERIVED_FROM
which-came-first: charity derives from gift; charity is institutionalized gift-giving.
- cmrcny8v4013c13vzwiowrct8← DERIVED_FROM
which-came-first: offering derives from gift; offering is ritualized gift to the divine.
- cmret9sqc012dg8vunyiepr10← DERIVED_FROM
Reciprocity derives from gift: the expectation of return is embedded in the gift-giving act. Which-came-first: the gift (transfer without immediate return) predates reciprocity (the principle that returns should follow). Gift creates the pattern that reciprocity formalizes.
- cmrevi9a1015sg8vumbpnhp6z← DERIVED_FROM
Altruism derives from gift: altruism is gift-giving generalized beyond social obligation into unconditional benefit-allocation.
- cmrfalrx0018wcqqt69rrhmac← DERIVED_FROM
Which-came-first: gift predates patronage; patronage is the formalization of gift-giving into structured, ongoing exchange with expected return.
- cmrclwiy100l99475m68yypq2← DERIVED_FROM
Gratitude derives from gift because gratitude is the recognition of an unearned benefit; without a gift, there is no gratitude.
- cmrclwiy100l99475m68yypq2← DEPENDS_ON
Gratitude depends on the prior existence of gift — without a received gift, gratitude has no object. You cannot be grateful for nothing.
- cmrcnnaet00or13vzpj13r52k← DEPENDS_ON
Charity depends on gift as its mechanism; the charitable act is an unreciprocated gift motivated by compassion.
- cmrbknt8d001da9g41pipqqbw← DERIVED_FROM
which-came-first: trade derives from gift; trade as structured exchange emerges from gift-giving rituals that establish reciprocity and value exchange norms.